There’s a common belief in the gym that if you're not hitting failure, you're not working hard enough. And sure, there's a certain rush to that last rep that brings out your forehead vein, but is it necessary?
Not really.
Training to failure isn’t a requirement for muscle growth — it’s just one tool in the box. And if you understand how to use it, you can get better results with less fatigue, fewer plateaus, and more long-term progress.
Let’s break down how it works — and when (or if) you should actually use it.
First, What Is Training to Failure?
Training to failure means performing an exercise until you physically can’t complete another rep with good form.
Not “it felt hard.” Not “my playlist ended.”
We’re talking true mechanical failure — your muscles give out.
There’s also:
- Momentary muscular failure: The point where you can’t complete another rep with proper form.
- Technical failure: The point where form breaks down and you compensate.
Most people stop at discomfort. Failure goes past that. Which brings us to the next question…
Is It Necessary to Build Muscle?
No. But it helps.
What really builds muscle is mechanical tension and proximity to failure — how close you get to that final, can’t-do-it rep.
Most of the muscle-building stimulus happens in the last 3–4 reps before failure. That’s where the highest tension and motor unit recruitment occur.
So, you don’t need to hit failure — but you do need to get close.
That’s why many lifters use RIR (Reps In Reserve) as a guideline:
-
2 RIR means you could do 2 more reps
-
0 RIR = failure
Training with 0–2 RIR is the sweet spot for hypertrophy. Any further away is still better than nothing, and it can be helpful if you’re just focusing on technique or are new to weight training. But in general, you’ll want to be near 0-2 RIR with all of your working sets.
So… Why Not Train to Failure All the Time?
Here’s the issue: training to failure increases fatigue a lot more than it increases stimulus.
The closer you get to failure:
- The harder it is to recover
- The more CNS fatigue you build up
- The more likely your technique breaks down (which can increase injury risk)
Especially with compound lifts like squats or deadlifts, failure can take a huge toll on your recovery — without a proportional benefit.
In other words, it’s diminishing returns with added risk.
When Training to Failure Can Be Useful
To Gauge Proximity to Failure
If you’ve never trained to failure, how do you know what 2 RIR feels like? You don’t. Occasionally taking a set to failure helps calibrate your internal gauge.
For Isolation Movements
Exercises like bicep curls or lateral raises have low systemic fatigue. Taking these to failure is less risky and easier to recover from.
In Low-Volume Training
If you’re doing fewer sets, pushing closer to failure can help ensure you’re still getting sufficient stimulus.
During Deloads or Special Phases
Some programs strategically use failure training in short bursts or for psychological challenge.
When to Avoid It
At the Start of a Program
Volume ramps up. No need to cook yourself early.
On Compound Lifts
Fatigue accumulates fast, and injury risk increases.
Additionally, when we approach failure on a compound lift like a squat, major muscle groups (quads, glutes) won’t activate fully; instead, supporting muscles (adductors, lower back) will coordinate to help complete the lift. So, you’re getting less stimulus than you think and adding more fatigue than you think.
If Recovery Is Compromised
Poor sleep, high stress, or calorie deficits already hit recovery hard. Failure training on top of that? Bad combo.
Better Than Failure: Consistency and Progression
Muscle growth is a long game. Training close to failure — consistently — with good technique and progressive overload will get you results without frying your nervous system.
Track your progress. Add reps. Add weight. Improve execution.
You’ll grow more in the long term with 8 good reps at 2 RIR than you will from 10 ugly, grinding ones that land you in snap city.
A Smarter Strategy
Here’s how to approach failure training with purpose:
Use RIR as your guide
Train most sets at 1–2 RIR. Save failure for accessory lifts or the last set of an exercise.
Cycle your intensity
Push closer to failure as a training block progresses. Week 1: 3 RIR, Week 4: 1 RIR. Then deload.
Focus on execution
Make sure the reps you're doing actually stimulate the muscle. Slow eccentrics, controlled tempo, no cheating.
Recover well
Sleep, eat, and rest. Failure training only works if your body can bounce back.
The Final Word
Training to failure can help. But it’s not magic — and it’s definitely not mandatory.
✔ Most of the hypertrophic benefit comes from being close to failure
✔ Constant failure training = fatigue > progress
✔ Use it wisely: for isolation lifts, testing RIR accuracy, or occasional overload
✔ Smart, consistent training will always beat heroic one-off efforts
You don’t have to fail every set to succeed long-term.
But knowing how to flirt with failure — without constantly crashing into it — is what separates the pros from the sore, overtrained, and under-recovered.
So, train hard, train smart, and save the failure for when it counts.
